I’d like to have a bag that has a handle on it that isn’t too big but capable of holding: IPhone in a dedicated pocket D ring or something for a small ID badge to clip on so easy to take off Car keys Small pocket light Pocket knife Billfold Small padlock Small case that is about 4 inches by 3 inches by 1 inch Inhaler Very small field note notepad Ideally along with the handle it’d have a hook to be able to hang it up, but could use a carbine on another D-ring too. I’d prefer it not to be tactical looking as well, but maybe I won’t have a chance in that. Any thoughts?
Why not to go custom to fit nearly 100% of your needings ? Our fellow EDCer @Bora here is a master in quality and precision with this kind of stuff ...
Bellroy, Peak Design, Waterfield. All 3 make bags which can handle what you describe, except perhaps the D-ring
Nutsac has some bags that can handle those items. I EDC the mag satch and have used their MBD with good results.
Hazard 4 Tonto might be a good fit. It's a small messnger style bag. I have the Kato which is the same bag just a bit bigger. Worked well for me.
A pocket organizer could handle most of that. If you went a little bigger, the Vanquest organizers seem like a good fit. https://www.vanquest.com/organizers-pouches/
Various vertical courier/messenger bags on the smaller end of the spectrum would meet all your requirements. Some of the smaller Tom Bihn organizational bags like the Snake Charmer. Small bags from the local bike shop. Something along the lines of a sew up saddleback/underseat tire bag should work. ATB, Sam